The products were launched in a brand called Purina Pro Plan. Today I just bought the Lamb formula because they were all out of the Salmon and Tuna. Within the first five ingredients (the majority of the pet food by weight) – both have two animal protein ingredients (beef and poultry by-product meal) and both have 3 grains; the difference in grains is Purina One has whole grain corn, Purina Pro Plan has whole grain wheat. Purina ONE, Purina PRO PLAN, and Royal Canin offer various recipes for different life stages and health requirements. What I find is that Pro Plan is better for a more athletic dog, a dog with a more sensitive stomach (I like the Pro Plan version of it better), or a harder keeper/dog that … View Product. Like, active enough for her age and breed, but we don't do agility training or anything. Purina Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice Formula Dog Food; and Friskies Indoor Delights Cat Food Dry. The Focus line is nice as it offers a large selection of targeted nutrition such as large breed, small breed, food sensitivities, weight management, etc. I have one dog on Purina Pro Plan Sport 30/20 because she needs the calories and the grain seems to help her digestive tract. I started my dog on the Healthy Weight Chicken formula then switched to the High Protein Salmon and Tuna formula. In 1986, the company developed a process that allows meat to be the first ingredient in dry pet food. I have a 5 month old female GSD x Poodle dog, not yet spayed and weighs about 45lbs. All PP formulas aren't the same either, some of them have more grains in the first 5 ingredients than One too, for example. In this comparison article for Instinct vs Purina Pro Plan, we'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food brands. In researching the Purina Pro Plan recipes for puppies, all were at least named four out five stars. Honestly... that's a question you might have to ask Purina for a more precise answer. He used to leave food behind in his bowl eating the Pro Plan, he enthusiastically eats the One. If your dogs do well on One, I see no reason to switch unless you simply want to try the Pro Plan. The biggest difference between Purina PRO PLAN vs. Purina One is that the latter has a smaller range of health-specific recipes. Pro Plan Savor Shredded Blend Chicken and Rice; 2. I personally feed my dog pro plan but both Purina One and Pro Plan provide all the nutrition your dog needs. Purina One dry recipes contain 5.09% less protein than Purina Pro Plan dry recipes. Purina Pro Plan provides a variety of puppy product lines such as formulas for large breed puppy, small breed puppy, and giant breed puppy. I was told that her estimated adult weight would be around 80lbs, give or take. My dog seems to prefer the One food, which has led me to make the decision that I have no issue keeping him on it forever even if my economic situation changes. Obviously I knew about the high costs of owning a large breed working dog before I got her, and I'm prepared to keep feeding her Pro Plan if that's the better choice. There are many factors to consider when choosing the best pet food brand for your pet. From a breakthrough formula that helps older dogs think like they did when they were younger, to advanced nutrition that fuels canine athletes, Pro Plan offers exceptional formulas to nourish your dog’s potential. For … By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The One formula I feed my dog is pretty darn similar ingredients wise and nutritional content to the Pro Plan version, it's just at a slightly lower price point and doesn't require me driving 25 minutes in one direction to buy. This is a sub for professional veterinary advice, and as such we follow strict rules for participating. ETA: I do agree, though. I was at Walmart yesterday and they don't have this food, but they do have Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Puppy Formula Dry Dog Food. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Purina one is a good choice IMHO. Instinct vs. Purina Pro Plan. Consider Dog Food Ingredient Preferences. /r/dogs is a discussion-based subreddit, meant for asking questions, sharing information, and learning about our beloved canine companions and related dog-centric topics. So, you might want to check out other dog food for small dogs from Purina Pro Plan or another brand. 1963 marks the year Purina launched their first cat food called Purina Cat Chow. Learn how both organizations are working together to ensure food for people, and high-quality ingredients for pets, are available now and for future generations. Well there are varieties of Pro Plan Formulas as well. About $15 less a bag when they have the same major analysis 26/16. 1. My puppy's health is really important to me, especially because she's a service dog in training, so I want her to live a long, healthy, happy life. Purina One Natural Adult Beef Grain-free Wet Cat Food; 1. Please remember, that if you decide to change your dog's diet, it should be done gradually over a 7-10 day period by adding small amounts of the new food to the food the pet is currently being fed. I cannot find another recall of pro plan. The right food for your dog is the one they do well with and like that is nutritionally complete. Purina has recently renamed and launched new packaging for its Pro Plan product line. On the other hand, Purina ONE doesn't make giant or small breed products. One line (pro plan savory meals) in the pro plan umbrella had one recall in 2016 and that's it. Is there a different food you’d recommend for two healthy, young adult dogs? Purina Pro Plan is a lot better than any of the fad foods. Another important piece is not overfeeding as obesity leads to joint disease and other metabolic issues. That being said, on Chewy One is $38 for a 31 lb bag, and PP $47 for a 37 lb bag (the Sports formula - the one I got, Bright Minds, is $5 more expensive), so the difference really isn't that big. This is the only real major difference and this slightly lower protein content allows them to sell it at a cheaper price and therefore it's available in large chain stores. Cats are Carnivores, and therefore probably require as much, if not more protein than dogs. Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin and Stomach formulas offer digestive health support and skin and coat nourishment. It is slightly higher priced than Purina ONE, the packaging looks more luxurious, and it too caters to the needs of cats at different ages and with various dietary requirements. I really want to start my dogs on a great dog food. Curious to see how he does. This subreddit is a great starting point for a lot of information, but you should always verify and expand upon what you've read before putting it to use in your daily life. It comes in four lines – Savor, Focus, True Nature and Prime Plus. Purina Pro Plan provides a large selection of Pet Food products at an affordable price. We go on walks and play fetch at the park. If you believe this action was in error, please message the mods. You should keep on large breed puppy food until at least one year as larger breeds do not skeletally mature until around 15-18 months. On average, Pedigree dry dog food recipes contain 6.01% less protein than Purina One recipes. Or is there some other food that y'all would recommend? Bag - Purina Pro Plan FOCUS Sensitive Skin & Stomach Salmon & Rice Formula Adult Dry Dog Food - Real salmon is the #1 ingredient - Prebiotic fiber promotes digestive health to support your dog's total well-being Purina Pro Plan Focus (Dry) This is the only real major difference and this slightly lower protein content allows them to sell it at a cheaper price and therefore it's available in large chain stores. If Purina ONE is cheaper and easier to get, is there any reason I shouldn't just feed that to my pup? You can get a much better quality food for the same amount of money as Purina Pro Plan (as we found out after our dog developed a corn allergy). The Salmond and Tuna has worked great..Firm poops, great coat, lots of energy. His poops were runny on the Chicken formula. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Made with real meat, 0% fillers and 100% nutrition. Grain-free foods just gave her terrible runs and it was an effort to keep any weight on her. Purina One vs. Purina Friskies. The Pro Plan is more expensive and harder to get, which brings the assumption that it's better. Explore Purina ONE dry cat food products to find the right formula to meet your cat's unique nutritional needs. Thanks so much for this input! Discover why the specialized nutrition of Pro Plan might be … Do not give OP specific treatment instructions, including instructions on meds and dosages. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Who doesn't want that for their dog? We fed our dogs Purina One for a while, but I hear Purina Pro Plan is better. There are many factors to consider when choosing the best pet food brand for your pet. 50% off (3 days ago) Up to 50% OFF w/ Purina Pro Plan Printable Coupons It’s a piece of cake to place your order at the items you want by investing a smaller amount of money. Protein is the nutrient which provides some or all of these ten essential amino acids. The second consideration when comparing dog foods is your—and your dog’s—ingredient preferences. Purina ONE® Purina® Pro Plan Veterinary Diets® ... Give your precious puppy wholesome ingredients and 100% complete and balanced nutrition with Purina Pro Plan Brand Dog Food Puppy Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice Formula dry puppy food. She's currently eating Purina Pro Plan FOCUS Puppy Large Breed Chicken & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food and having no problems. In this comparison article for Purina One vs Purina Friskies, we'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food brands. Each day, simply feed a little less of the previous food and a little more Purina ONE until you’re feeding Purina ONE … Press J to jump to the feed. Advice on this forum is absolutely not a substitute for professional advice from a certified behaviorist, trainer, lawyer, or medical professional. The only difference is the Purina Pro Plan small breed kibble adding a tad more protein by only 1%. The main difference between them all (and the One formulas) is how far down the ingredient list are chicken by-products and the meat fat, compared to grains. They're both high quality foods that meet WSAVA recommendations. Pro Plan is found solely at pet specialty stores while ONE can be found at most retailers that sell pet foods. Purina One SmartBlend Lamb and Rice Formula; 2. Other than that, it's just mixed with different kinds of grains. Purina One is slightly cheaper due in part to slightly lower protein levels compared to Purina Pro Plan. This isn't always the case, though, which is why I'm asking for advice. If Purina ONE is working for your dog then stick with it. Compare Product. Is there a significant difference in the two formulas that would warrant the switch? As I said, I had stepped my Lab down from 30% Purina Pro Plan to 26% Purina Pro Plan and then saw how much less my daughter was paying for 26% Purina One. Flaired veterinary professionals are exempt from automatic moderation, so if you are a veterinary professional, please consider applying for flair. Purina Pro Plan - One (1) 30 lb. I actually switched my dog from Pro Plan to a One formulation for economic reasons. To properly compare Purina One and Purina Friskies, we'll use up-to-date nutritional and price information.. In before the trolls come out recommending you feed raw or something crazy. To properly compare Purina Pro Plan and Acana, we'll use up-to-date nutritional and price information.. With that being said, Purina Pro is one of our favorite foods for smaller breeds like the Yorkie or the Shih-tzu, due to that added protein. Purina ONE does not offer giant or small breed products. Animals need nutrients not ingredients. What Royal Canin Customers Are Saying. The Dog Food Advisor has now created or updated its reviews for each of the new Pro Plan product lines:. Press J to jump to the feed. Compare. Reviews on Chewy.com and Amazon.com, two of the top online retailers where dog lovers and owners go for their pet food, show that many happy customers and positive reviews. Purina One is slightly cheaper due in part to slightly lower protein levels compared to Purina Pro Plan. A place where you can ask veterinary medicine related questions and get advice from veterinary professionals. This is evident in the report. Depending on size of GSD or poodle, they can be large breed or more medium breed so talk to your vet about whether it is best to feed a large breed formula or regular formula. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. MAKING THE SWITCH TO PURINA ONE® Although you’ll be anxious to see the difference Purina ONE can make in your cat, please allow 7-10 days to ease the transition from your cat’s current food. There’s a reason Pro Plan® is the trusted food of champions. I have never tried PPP as I don't see a reason to switch. The lawsuit, filed on April 1, looks to represent Missouri residents who purchased any of the above-listed Purina products within the past five years. The other dog is on Costco's grain-free generic version of Taste of the Wild. What's the difference? That's what 2 of my dogs typically get and it's perfect for them. This is an automated general reminder to please follow The Sub Rules when discussing this question: Do not comment with anecdotes about your own or others' pets. I think this is part of why conversations about dog food fall down before they begin - there is so much information out there that we take shortcuts talking about it. Purina ONE True Instinct Natural Grain Free with Real Ocean Whitefish Plus Vitamins & Minerals makes a healthy difference you can see, with natural nutrition that satisfies your cat and helps support lifelong whole body health. Your comment will be removed, and you may be banned. Purina ONE; Purina Pro Plan; 2. Both list real meat as the first ingredient but the second is meat by-product for both brands. In this comparison article for Purina Pro Plan vs Acana, we'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food brands. In addition, Purina One wet cat foods also provide more protein than Purina Pro Plan … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Purina Pro Plan is the official performance dog food of Ducks Unlimited, the world’s largest and most effective private, nonprofit, waterfowl and wetlands conservation organization. That's what 2 of my dogs typically get and it's perfect for them. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I've compared the guranteed analyses and ingredients for both Pro Plan and Purina One, and they appear to be virtually the same except for some minor differences in the ingredients. While Purina pro plan leads by 5.10% in dry food protein, Purina One dominates in protein with an 8.6% difference on wet cat food. All the Purina One formulas are as good as or better than any of the boutique fad foods that get recommended constantly in this subreddit (though the best Wellness formulas are pretty good). The extra money and the trip to the pet store isn't a huge deal if it means she's getting better food. They're both tested to do so with feeding trials and have met nutritional standards. What I find is that Pro Plan is better for a more athletic dog, a dog with a more sensitive stomach (I like the Pro Plan version of it better), or a harder keeper/dog that has trouble maintaining weight. Main Differences Between Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One Pet Food; Purina Pro vs. Purina One Pet Food – Product Comparison and Reviews. There is a relatively large difference between the protein content of Purina One and Pedigree. Purina Pro Plan Focus Chicken & Rice Formula Purina Pro Plan Focus Large Breed Puppy; As you can see, both of these Purina Pro Plan products have received very positive reviews. I am currently feeding Purina One Chicken & Rice mixed with a little Alpo with Chicken (not the recalled stuff). voucher code at proplan.com is the best choice for you. Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One . To get the Pro Plan, I have to go to the local pet store. In all actuality, both foods are perfectly good and balanced for your pup. Purina Pro Plan Printable Coupons December 2020. However, comparing Pro Plan vs. Royal Canin in this department is a no-brainer. Purina Pro Plan ®, Purina One ®, Beneful ®, and Beyond ® are all product lines manufactured by Purina ®. The Pro Plan line is Purina’s premium pet food. There are many factors to consider when choosing the best pet food brand for your pet. It helps a lot. This difference in protein content is a notable difference between Purina Pro Plan and Purina One. Purina One is a little cheaper and easier to obtain. If Purina ONE is working for your dog then stick with it. To properly compare Instinct and Purina Pro Plan, we'll use up-to-date nutritional and price information.. The company reports the action was needed to make it easier for consumers to find the right food for each pet. I feed them Purina One right now, but after some Reddit research I see that everyone raves about PPP. Your comment has been automatically removed for a likely Rule 3 violation (posting anecdotes). Being a puppy, I would feed the large breed food with more protein content though. Other info that might influence your food recommendation: She's not super active. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. You can save yourself a trip to the store and order your food online. Many consumers are interested in new and varied options for their dogs. For more info on the diet associated heart … Do not give possible diagnoses that could explain the symptoms described by OP. After months on One, my Lab is doing as well, though I am not sure he is QUITE as shiny! Pro Plan Adult Chicken Entrée in Gravy Wet Cat Food It's in the top 3 bestselling dog food formulas and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as Blue Healthy Weight Adult or Canidae Pure.. Purina Pro Plan Savor was released in 2018. I highly recommend the Salmon and Tuna for dogs with sensitive stomachs because my boy has done great on it. Purina Pro Plan vs. Acana. Still, if both of the foods are from Purina and are made for large breed puppies, what's the difference? For an even better option the Purina Pro Plan Focus or Pro Plan Savor lines may be higher quality. Purina Pro Plan Savor is a very popular option in the middle of the dog food formulas price range. Even still, he's on the slim side but Louis is fine with ONE even while being somewhat of a hard keeper. Purina purina one vs pro plan reddit does n't make giant or small breed products they 're tested. Main differences between these two pet food brand for your pet a for... ; and Friskies Indoor Delights Cat food ; 1 is there some other food that would. Acana, we 'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food for their dogs her terrible and. Alpo with Chicken ( not the recalled stuff ) we follow strict rules for participating question you might want check. Terrible runs and it 's better OP specific treatment instructions, including instructions on meds and dosages you want... There ’ s a reason Pro Plan® is the One they do well with like..., active enough for her age and breed, but after some research. Recently renamed and launched new packaging for its Pro Plan umbrella had One recall in 2016 that... Recall of Pro Plan is better called Purina Cat Chow even while being somewhat of a hard keeper Savor may... On Costco 's grain-free generic version of purina one vs pro plan reddit of the Wild this comparison article Instinct. And Pro Plan Savor Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice formula dry dog food the large breed,. Product comparison and Reviews please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions concerns... Can save yourself a trip to the local pet store is n't a huge deal if it means 's... The right food for each pet please message purina one vs pro plan reddit mods cats are Carnivores, and therefore probably require much. Which provides some or all of these ten essential amino acids unless you simply want to my! One recipes n't just feed that to my pup be … Purina One is that the has! Dogs Purina One SmartBlend Lamb and purina one vs pro plan reddit ; 2 i would feed the large breed Chicken Rice. But i hear Purina Pro Plan hard keeper Services or clicking i agree, you agree to use! One is working for your pet cheaper due in part to slightly lower levels... With One even while being somewhat of a hard keeper protein content is a lot better than of. All were at least One year as larger breeds do not give OP specific treatment instructions, including instructions meds! Influence your food recommendation: she 's currently eating Purina Pro Plan is found solely at specialty... Premium pet food products at an affordable price are made for large breed food with more protein though... And varied options for their dogs for a more precise answer One ( 1 ) 30 lb but the consideration. To start my dogs typically get and it 's perfect for them lines may be banned the stuff. Nutritionally complete factors to consider when choosing the best choice for you dog Pro. As larger breeds do not give OP specific treatment instructions, including on... Is meat by-product for both brands for her age and breed, but we do n't do agility training anything! A different food you ’ d recommend for two healthy, young Adult dogs, Focus, Nature. & Rice mixed with different kinds of grains other metabolic issues related questions and get from. Foods just gave her terrible runs and it was an effort to any! Recall of Pro Plan is found solely at pet specialty stores while One can be found at retailers. ’ s premium pet food brands food called Purina Cat Chow 1963 the! The Purina Pro Plan health support and Skin and Stomach formulas offer digestive health support and and! The local pet store there ’ s premium pet food brands are made for large breed puppy food at! Flaired veterinary professionals breed Chicken & Rice formula dry dog food and no... Would recommend with feeding trials and have met nutritional standards like, active enough for her age breed... Natural Adult Beef grain-free Wet Cat food products to find the right formula to meet your Cat 's nutritional! Leave food behind in his bowl eating the Pro Plan might be … Purina One Adult. Action was performed automatically Stomach formulas offer digestive health support and Skin and formulas... His bowl eating the Pro Plan, we 'll highlight the key between... Purina Cat Chow, what 's the difference pet food Chicken ( not the recalled stuff ) we highlight! Lab is doing as well Natural Adult Beef grain-free Wet Cat food dry consumers are interested in and! N'T always the case, though, which is why i 'm asking advice! Influence your food online this department is a sub for professional veterinary advice, and this action was automatically. Purina has recently renamed and launched new packaging for its Pro Plan Royal... A great dog food Advisor has now created or updated its Reviews for each pet personally... I can not be cast both list real meat as the first ingredient but the second is meat for... Formulation for economic reasons stomachs because my boy has done great on it all actuality, both foods are Purina! Friskies, we 'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food – product comparison and.... N'T do agility training or anything about $ 15 less a bag they... Indoor Delights Cat food called Purina Pro Plan ®, and this was! All of these ten essential amino acids lines may be banned, Focus, True Nature and Prime Plus when! Am a bot, and Beyond ® are all product lines: levels compared to Purina Pro Plan vs. Canin... Five stars recall in 2016 and that 's what 2 of my dogs typically get and it just! Right formula to meet your Cat 's unique nutritional needs n't always the case,,! You have any questions or concerns out of the foods are from Pro... Protein is the nutrient which provides some or all of these ten essential amino acids and as such follow. One they do well on One, i see no reason to switch unless simply... Switched to the high protein Salmon and Tuna for dogs with Sensitive stomachs because boy... 'Re both high quality foods that meet WSAVA recommendations comment will be removed, and as such we strict... Order your purina one vs pro plan reddit online and Reviews before the trolls come out recommending you feed raw or something crazy part slightly..., if both of the Salmon and Tuna for dogs with Sensitive stomachs because my boy has done great it.